The rule
Elements of a process of experimentation
- Identify the uncertainty State the capability, method or design question the team could not answer at the outset.
- Identify alternatives Formulate hypotheses or candidate designs intended to eliminate the uncertainty.
- Evaluate alternatives Test, model, simulate, prototype or analyse the alternatives systematically.
- Refine or discard Use results to refine hypotheses or select a design; iterate as needed.
- Record conclusions Document what was learned, including failures.
Methods that can constitute experimentation
| Method | What makes it experimental | What makes it routine |
|---|---|---|
| Systematic evaluation of alternatives | Comparing candidate designs against defined criteria where the best choice is unknown | Selecting from a catalogue by known specifications |
| Testing | Tests designed to answer an open technical question | Routine quality-control or acceptance testing |
| Prototypes | Building to learn whether a design works | Building a production unit from a finished design |
| Modeling and simulation | FEA, CFD or performance models used to evaluate alternatives | Running a standard calculation to document compliance |
| Design iterations | Revisions driven by test or analysis results | Cosmetic or customer-preference revisions |
| Engineering analysis | Analysis to resolve which approach will meet requirements | Code-compliance checks with known outcomes |
| Trial and error | Structured, recorded trials with hypotheses | Unstructured tinkering without evaluation |
| Validation | Validation that tests whether uncertain design goals are met | Validation after the design is final and known to work (may be after commercial production) |
Examples by industry
Distributed system architecture
A team designing a multi-region replication system faced uncertainty about achieving consistency and failover targets under network partitions. They modeled three consensus approaches and ran fault-injection tests.
Business component: Replication subsystem
Potentially qualifying factors
- Modeling and simulation of alternatives
- Fault-injection experiments with recorded outcomes
- Design iterations driven by test results
Potential exclusion issues
- Deploying the chosen design to production
- Operations and on-call work
- Configuration of managed cloud services without experimentation
Documentation required
- Design documents comparing alternatives
- Fault-injection test logs
- Version-control history
- Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
- Records of alternatives evaluated and results
- Time allocation for personnel involved
Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.
Tolerance refinement
A precision component required tolerances tighter than the shop had achieved. Machinists and engineers trialed tooling paths, fixtures and thermal controls.
Business component: Precision shaft (product) and machining method (process)
Potentially qualifying factors
- Uncertainty about method to achieve tolerance
- Iterative trials with measurement data
Potential exclusion issues
- Routine first-article inspection
- Production runs after the method was established
Documentation required
- CMM measurement data by trial
- Fixture design iterations
- Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
- Records of alternatives evaluated and results
- Time allocation for personnel involved
Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.
Structural analysis
An engineering firm designing an unusual long-span roof could not determine from codes alone whether the proposed system would meet deflection limits. It modeled alternatives and iterated the design.
Business component: Roof structural system design
Potentially qualifying factors
- Uncertainty beyond code-prescribed solutions
- Iterative modeling of alternatives
Potential exclusion issues
- Routine code-compliance calculations
- Funded research if the client pays regardless of outcome and owns the results
Documentation required
- Model iterations
- Design memos
- Contract terms on risk and rights
- Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
- Records of alternatives evaluated and results
- Time allocation for personnel involved
Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.
Formulation testing
A food manufacturer sought to reduce sodium by 30% while maintaining texture and microbial stability through processing. Food scientists trialed alternative salt replacers and processing parameters.
Business component: Reduced-sodium product formulation
Potentially qualifying factors
- Functional objectives (stability, texture under processing)
- Structured bench and pilot trials
Potential exclusion issues
- Taste-preference panels alone
- Seasonal flavor variants
- Packaging graphics
Documentation required
- Formulation trial records
- Lab analyses
- Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
- Records of alternatives evaluated and results
- Time allocation for personnel involved
Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.
Growing-condition experimentation
A grower tested irrigation schedules and substrate mixes to determine whether a crop variety could be grown profitably in a hotter climate zone.
Business component: Growing process for a crop variety
Potentially qualifying factors
- Controlled plots with recorded variables
- Reliance on agronomy and plant science
Potential exclusion issues
- Routine farming practices
- Weather-driven adjustments without experimental design
Documentation required
- Plot designs and yield data
- Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
- Records of alternatives evaluated and results
- Time allocation for personnel involved
Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.
Materials
A company evaluated polymer blends for a flexible housing that needed to withstand repeated sterilization cycles.
Business component: Device housing material
Potentially qualifying factors
- Material trials with sterilization-cycle testing
- Supplies consumed in trials
Potential exclusion issues
- Selecting a material with known certified properties
Documentation required
- Material trial matrices
- Sterilization test data
- Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
- Records of alternatives evaluated and results
- Time allocation for personnel involved
Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.
Evidence of experimentation
- Test plans, protocols and results.
- Design review minutes showing alternatives considered.
- Version-control history, pull requests and benchmark results for software.
- Simulation input files and outputs.
- Prototype build records and failure analyses.
- Lab notebooks and electronic lab records.
Practical examples of experimentation activities
- Prototype iteration
- Evaluating engineering alternatives
- Simulation
- Testing
- Modeling
- Design iterations
- A/B evaluation of technical alternatives, where appropriate
- Laboratory trials
- Manufacturing trials
- Evaluating software architecture alternatives
Frequently asked questions
Does the process of experimentation require a formal scientific method?
No formal lab setting is required, but the process must be designed to evaluate alternatives to resolve technical uncertainty and rely on scientific, engineering or computer-science principles. Structured, recorded trial and error can qualify.
What if only part of a project involves experimentation?
The 'substantially all' requirement is applied per business component. If less than 80% of activities are experimental, the shrinking-back rule may identify a subcomponent that qualifies.
Official sources
Explore State R&D Tax Credits
A neutral selection of state research, listed alphabetically. A federal credit does not determine a state credit: some state programs incorporate federal concepts, while others use state-specific definitions and calculations.
Calculator available
Specialized programs
All state R&D tax credits · Compare state rules · State changes by year
General research and educational information, not legal or tax advice. Rules may vary by tax year and taxpayer-specific facts may affect results. See the disclaimer.