Businesses in this industry may conduct activities that potentially meet the qualified-research requirements. Industry alone does not determine eligibility. Explore credits with the R&D Credit Finder.
What R&D can look like
- Prototype development for new devices.
- Verification testing of uncertain designs.
- Materials evaluation for biocompatibility and durability.
- Mechanical design iteration.
Research topics in medical devices
Device design and development
Developing a new or improved device where safety, performance or reliability is uncertain may involve qualified research evaluated through design iterations, bench testing and verification.
Design controls and documentation
Regulatory design-control records — design inputs, outputs, verification and validation — often document uncertainty and experimentation, although regulatory records do not by themselves establish qualification.
Clinical studies
Clinical research may involve qualified research, but research conducted outside the United States is excluded from the federal credit, and funded or sponsored studies need funded-research review.
Manufacturing processes
Developing processes to manufacture a device reliably at scale can be a separate business component.
Potential business components
The four-part test is applied to each business component. Examples in this industry:
- A new or improved device
- A device subsystem (sensor, firmware, mechanism)
- A manufacturing or sterilization process
- Device software
Common technical uncertainties
- Whether a design achieves required accuracy and biocompatibility
- Which mechanism meets reliability requirements over the device life
- Whether a process consistently meets specifications
Potential experimentation
- Bench and verification testing of design alternatives
- Iterative prototyping
- Process validation experiments
The four-part test in medical devices
| Test | Application |
|---|---|
| Permitted purpose | Safety, performance and reliability. |
| Technological in nature | Biomedical engineering and materials science. |
| Uncertainty | Design capability under clinical conditions. |
| Process of experimentation | Bench testing, simulation, prototype iteration. |
Project examples
Prototype development
A device company developed a new catheter. The overall device used known elements, but the tip geometry needed to navigate tortuous vessels was uncertain.
Business component: Catheter (shrinking back to tip design)
Potentially qualifying factors
- Shrinking-back to the uncertain subcomponent
- Bench-top prototypes and simulated-use testing
Potential exclusion issues
- Regulatory submission preparation
- Clinical activities after design is final may raise post-production questions
Documentation required
- Design history file entries
- Test reports
- Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
- Records of alternatives evaluated and results
- Time allocation for personnel involved
Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.
Testing
Engineers ran fatigue and biocompatibility screening on candidate designs to determine which met durability requirements.
Business component: Implantable device component
Potentially qualifying factors
- Testing of alternatives against uncertain requirements
Potential exclusion issues
- Routine lot-release testing
Documentation required
- Verification test protocols
- Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
- Records of alternatives evaluated and results
- Time allocation for personnel involved
Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.
Materials
A company evaluated polymer blends for a flexible housing that needed to withstand repeated sterilization cycles.
Business component: Device housing material
Potentially qualifying factors
- Material trials with sterilization-cycle testing
- Supplies consumed in trials
Potential exclusion issues
- Selecting a material with known certified properties
Documentation required
- Material trial matrices
- Sterilization test data
- Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
- Records of alternatives evaluated and results
- Time allocation for personnel involved
Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.
Mechanical design
Designers iterated a surgical instrument's actuation mechanism to reduce required hand force while maintaining precision.
Business component: Instrument actuation mechanism
Potentially qualifying factors
- Design iterations with force measurements
Potential exclusion issues
- Ergonomic styling changes
Documentation required
- CAD revisions
- Force test results
- Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
- Records of alternatives evaluated and results
- Time allocation for personnel involved
Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.
QRE examples
Wages
- Design engineers, test technicians
Supplies
- Prototype materials
QRE rules: qualified research expenses.
Documentation
- Design history file
- Verification test reports
- Design review minutes
Potential non-qualifying activities
The statutory exclusions in IRC §41(d)(4) — such as research after commercial production, adaptation or duplication of an existing component, routine quality-control testing, foreign research and funded research — apply to medical devices projects in the same way as any other industry. The qualified research page lists each exclusion with its source.
Relevant federal rules: four-part test, qualified research, funded research, research location. Build a documentation checklist.
Federal R&D credit considerations
- Research outside the United States is excluded — see research location.
- Device software may raise software classification questions.
- Start-ups may consider the payroll tax election if they are qualified small businesses.
Industry-specific caveats
- Regulatory submission preparation and post-market surveillance are generally not research.
- Work after commercial release may be post-production activity.
- Sponsored or grant-funded work requires funded-research review.
Start with the federal R&D tax credit and qualified research expenses; estimate with the federal R&D credit calculator.
Common mistakes
- Claiming regulatory submission preparation as research.
State considerations
- Minnesota and Florida have concentrations of device manufacturers; both require in-state research.
Potentially relevant active state programs: Minnesota, Florida, Massachusetts, California, Utah.
Calculators: Minnesota R&D Tax Credit Calculator, Florida R&D Tax Credit Calculator, Massachusetts R&D Tax Credit Calculator, California R&D Tax Credit Calculator, Utah R&D Tax Credit Calculator.
Frequently asked questions
Do design controls help documentation?
Design history files and design reviews often contain contemporaneous evidence of uncertainty and experimentation.
Official sources
General research and educational information, not legal or tax advice. Rules vary by tax year and taxpayer-specific facts affect results. See the disclaimer.