State research tool
Compare State R&D Tax Credit Rules
Compare state research credit programs, calculation methods, eligibility provisions, refundability, filing requirements, and official sources side by side.
Comparison: Compares recorded program rules; it does not rank states or estimate a credit.
Comparisons describe differences in program rules; they do not rank states or determine which program is best for a particular taxpayer. Fields with no recorded rule say “Not specified in this record” rather than being estimated.
| Rule | California CAOpen calculator for California | Texas TXOpen calculator for Texas | Delaware DEOpen calculator for Delaware |
|---|---|---|---|
| Program overview | |||
| Program status | Active | Active | Active |
| Current credit | California Research Credit: 15% regular QRE component; 24% basic research (eligible corporations); 2025+ ASC 3% (1.3% without full three-year history) | Texas Research and Development Activities Franchise Tax Credit (Subchapter T): 8.722% (10.903% with a qualifying higher-education contract); 4.361% (5.451%) of current Texas QREs without QREs in one or more of the 3 preceding tax periods | Delaware Research and Development Tax Credit: Method A: 10% (20% small business) of Delaware QREs over the Delaware base amount. Method B: 50% (100% small business) of Delaware's apportioned share of the federal Alternative Simplified Credit. |
| Credit method | Regular (fixed base with California amounts); AIC through 2024; California ASC from 2025 | Current Texas QREs minus 50% of the average Texas QREs for the three preceding tax periods | Annual election of Method A (Delaware fixed base) or Method B (apportioned federal ASC), independent of the federal method |
| Effective / expiration | Effective: California ASC for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2025 (SB 711)Expiration: No general sunset identified; the $5 million limitation applies to taxable years beginning before January 1, 2027 | Effective: Reports originally due on or after January 1, 2026Expiration: No expiration date in Subchapter T | Effective: Current rules for tax years beginning after December 31, 2016Expiration: No general sunset identified |
| Credit treatment | |||
| Small-business treatment | No separate small-business rate | No separate small-business rate; a refundable credit is available to qualifying entities that owe no franchise tax | Statutory threshold: $20 million, subject to annual adjustment (average annual gross receipts under IRC §41(c)(1)(B)) — $25,318,000 for 2024, $26,071,000 for 2025, $26,767,000 for 2026 |
| Refundability | Generally nonrefundable. However, for tax years 2024–2026, credits disallowed because of the $5 million business-credit limitation may be eligible for an irrevocable future refundable-credit election under the applicable California rules and Form FTB 3870. Credit limited by tax liability receives ordinary carryover treatment. | Only for qualifying entities that owe no franchise tax and meet the statutory requirements (Form 05-183) | Unused approved credit may be paid in the nature of a tax refund when the taxpayer cannot use the entire approved credit (§2070(c)) |
| Carryforward | Until exhausted; applied to the earliest taxable year possible; no general carryback | Up to 20 consecutive reports | Delaware's current program addresses unused approved credit through its refund treatment rather than a standard multi-year carryforward |
| Administration | |||
| Application required | No pre-approval; computed on Form FTB 3523 and claimed with the return | No pre-approval; claimed on the franchise tax report (refundable credit: Form 05-183 application) | Required — the Division of Revenue must approve the credit |
| Application deadline | With the return; the ASC election is made on a timely filed original return | With the franchise tax report; Form 05-183 by November 15 of the report year | Delaware R&D credit application deadline: September 15 following the taxable year |
| Research location requirement | Research must be conducted in California | Research conducted in Texas | Delaware |
| Official authority | California Franchise Tax Board | Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts | Delaware Division of Revenue |
| Research transparency | |||
| Research status | Verified | Verified | Verified |
| Last verified | Rules last verified October 2, 2026Research date: October 2, 2026 | Rules last verified October 5, 2026Research date: October 5, 2026 | Rules last verified October 3, 2026Research date: October 3, 2026 |
| Tax years researched | 2024, 2025, 2026 | 2024, 2025, 2026, 2027 | 2024, 2025, 2026 |
| Calculator availability | Calculator verifiedVerified for 2024–2026Open the California calculator | Calculator verifiedVerified for 2024–2027Open the Texas calculator | Calculator verifiedVerified for 2024, 2025Open the Delaware calculator |
How to interpret this comparison
Nominal credit rates are not directly comparable when states use different calculation methods, expense definitions, caps, or eligibility requirements. Research location, tax year, filing requirements, and taxpayer-specific facts can materially affect the outcome. Review each state’s official sources and applicable rules before relying on a comparison.
Program status, research status and calculator status are separate: a verified research record does not mean a calculator exists or has been verified. Research verification applies to the tax years researched shown in the table. See the state research table for every field and source, the state directory, the methodology and the official source library.