Resources

R&D Project Examples Library

Anonymized, illustrative examples. Each explains potentially qualifying factors, potential exclusion issues and the documentation required. None implies automatic qualification.

Software

Example · Software

API architecture experimentation

A software company needed a public API able to serve 10x its existing request volume with p99 latency under 100 ms. The team was uncertain whether an event-driven design or a synchronous gateway with caching would meet the target.

Business component: Public API platform (software held for license)

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Uncertainty about appropriate design to meet measurable performance targets
  • Alternatives (event-driven vs. cached synchronous) evaluated through load testing
  • Reliance on computer-science principles (concurrency, caching, queuing theory)
Potential exclusion issues
  • Routine endpoint development using established patterns
  • Work after the API was released to customers (post-commercial production)
  • Documentation and developer-portal content
Documentation required
  • Architecture decision records
  • Load-test plans and results
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Example · Software

Database optimization

Queries on a multi-tenant database degraded as data grew. The team did not know whether partitioning, alternative indexing or a columnar store would restore performance without breaking consistency guarantees.

Business component: Data layer of a commercial SaaS product

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Uncertainty about method and design
  • Benchmarking of alternative schemas and indexes
  • Iterative refinement based on measured results
Potential exclusion issues
  • Applying a vendor's documented tuning guide without uncertainty
  • Routine maintenance and monitoring
  • Data migration after the design was settled
Documentation required
  • Benchmark scripts and results
  • Tickets linking experiments to findings
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Example · Software

Distributed system architecture

A team designing a multi-region replication system faced uncertainty about achieving consistency and failover targets under network partitions. They modeled three consensus approaches and ran fault-injection tests.

Business component: Replication subsystem

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Modeling and simulation of alternatives
  • Fault-injection experiments with recorded outcomes
  • Design iterations driven by test results
Potential exclusion issues
  • Deploying the chosen design to production
  • Operations and on-call work
  • Configuration of managed cloud services without experimentation
Documentation required
  • Design documents comparing alternatives
  • Fault-injection test logs
  • Version-control history
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Example · Software

Performance optimization

A mobile application's rendering pipeline could not meet frame-rate targets on low-end devices. Engineers evaluated alternative rendering strategies with profiling.

Business component: Rendering engine

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Measurable performance objective
  • Systematic profiling and evaluation of alternatives
Potential exclusion issues
  • Cosmetic UI changes
  • Bug fixes after release unrelated to uncertainty
Documentation required
  • Profiling data
  • Benchmark comparisons
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Example · Software

Security architecture

A company designed a new key-management scheme for tenant data isolation and was uncertain whether it could meet latency constraints. It prototyped and tested two cryptographic designs.

Business component: Encryption and key-management component

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Technical uncertainty on design and performance
  • Prototype evaluation of alternatives
Potential exclusion issues
  • Compliance audits and policy writing
  • Routine penetration testing of a finished system
  • Implementing a standard library as documented
Documentation required
  • Threat models and design comparisons
  • Performance test data
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Example · Software

Machine-learning experimentation

A team sought to build a model to predict equipment failure from sensor data. It did not know which features or architectures would achieve the required precision, and ran structured experiments across candidates.

Business component: Predictive-maintenance model (software)

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Experiment tracking of model architectures and features
  • Evaluation against defined metrics
Potential exclusion issues
  • Routine data collection and labeling
  • Model retraining in production on a fixed pipeline
  • Market research on customer demand
Documentation required
  • Experiment-tracking logs
  • Evaluation reports
  • Cloud GPU usage allocated to experiments
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Manufacturing

Example · Manufacturing

Material testing

A manufacturer needed a lighter bracket that would survive cyclic loading. It tested three alloys and two heat treatments to failure.

Business component: Lightweight bracket (product)

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Uncertainty about capability and design
  • Destructive testing of alternatives
  • Engineering analysis of failure modes
Potential exclusion issues
  • Routine incoming material inspection
  • Testing to confirm specification compliance for production lots
Documentation required
  • Test protocols and results
  • Material consumption records
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Example · Manufacturing

Process optimization

A plant sought to raise yield on a stamping line. Engineers evaluated die designs and press parameters in controlled trials.

Business component: Stamping process (plant process)

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Process treated as separate business component
  • Designed experiments with recorded parameters
Potential exclusion issues
  • Routine adjustments by operators
  • Efficiency studies without technical uncertainty
Documentation required
  • Design-of-experiments plans
  • Yield data
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Example · Manufacturing

Tolerance refinement

A precision component required tolerances tighter than the shop had achieved. Machinists and engineers trialed tooling paths, fixtures and thermal controls.

Business component: Precision shaft (product) and machining method (process)

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Uncertainty about method to achieve tolerance
  • Iterative trials with measurement data
Potential exclusion issues
  • Routine first-article inspection
  • Production runs after the method was established
Documentation required
  • CMM measurement data by trial
  • Fixture design iterations
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Example · Manufacturing

Tooling development

A manufacturer designed new injection-mold tooling for a part with complex geometry. The overall product was a known design, but the tooling's cooling layout was uncertain.

Business component: Mold tooling (shrinking back from the finished product)

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Shrinking-back to the tooling subcomponent where uncertainty existed
  • Mold-flow simulation of cooling alternatives
Potential exclusion issues
  • Duplicating existing tooling
  • Tooling that is depreciable property (not a supply QRE)
Documentation required
  • Simulation files
  • Tooling design revisions
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Example · Manufacturing

Load testing

An equipment maker redesigned a frame to carry higher loads and was uncertain which cross-section would meet fatigue targets. It combined FEA with physical load tests.

Business component: Equipment frame

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Modeling plus physical testing
  • Design changes driven by results
Potential exclusion issues
  • Certification testing of a finished design
  • Tests required by a customer contract that funds the work
Documentation required
  • FEA models
  • Load-test reports
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Example · Manufacturing

Prototype development

A company built functional prototypes of a new valve to determine whether a novel seal geometry would prevent leakage at high pressure.

Business component: High-pressure valve

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Prototypes built to test uncertain designs
  • Supplies consumed in prototypes
Potential exclusion issues
  • Prototypes later sold to customers
  • Pre-production pilot runs after design freeze
Documentation required
  • Prototype build records
  • Leak-test results
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Engineering

Example · Engineering

Structural analysis

An engineering firm designing an unusual long-span roof could not determine from codes alone whether the proposed system would meet deflection limits. It modeled alternatives and iterated the design.

Business component: Roof structural system design

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Uncertainty beyond code-prescribed solutions
  • Iterative modeling of alternatives
Potential exclusion issues
  • Routine code-compliance calculations
  • Funded research if the client pays regardless of outcome and owns the results
Documentation required
  • Model iterations
  • Design memos
  • Contract terms on risk and rights
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Example · Engineering

Design alternatives

A mechanical engineering team evaluated three cooling approaches for an electronics enclosure operating in extreme heat.

Business component: Enclosure thermal design

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Evaluation of alternatives with thermal modeling and testing
Potential exclusion issues
  • Selecting a standard catalogue solution without uncertainty
Documentation required
  • CFD results
  • Test data
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Example · Engineering

Simulation

A firm used computational fluid dynamics to evaluate alternative inlet geometries for an industrial fan to reduce noise while maintaining flow.

Business component: Fan inlet design

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Simulation as a method of evaluating alternatives
Potential exclusion issues
  • Simulations run only to document a known design
Documentation required
  • Simulation inputs/outputs
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Example · Engineering

Performance testing

An engineering team tested a new pump control algorithm across operating conditions to determine whether it met efficiency targets.

Business component: Pump control system

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Testing designed to resolve performance uncertainty
Potential exclusion issues
  • Acceptance testing required after design completion
Documentation required
  • Test matrices and results
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Food & Beverage

Example · Food & Beverage

Formulation testing

A food manufacturer sought to reduce sodium by 30% while maintaining texture and microbial stability through processing. Food scientists trialed alternative salt replacers and processing parameters.

Business component: Reduced-sodium product formulation

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Functional objectives (stability, texture under processing)
  • Structured bench and pilot trials
Potential exclusion issues
  • Taste-preference panels alone
  • Seasonal flavor variants
  • Packaging graphics
Documentation required
  • Formulation trial records
  • Lab analyses
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Example · Food & Beverage

Shelf-life experimentation

A producer wanted to extend refrigerated shelf life from 21 to 45 days. It tested preservation methods and packaging atmospheres with microbial challenge studies.

Business component: Product formulation and packaging process

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Measurable reliability/quality objective
  • Challenge studies evaluating alternatives
Potential exclusion issues
  • Routine shelf-life verification of an established product
  • Regulatory labeling work
Documentation required
  • Challenge-study protocols and results
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Example · Food & Beverage

Process optimization

A bakery scaled a new product from pilot to production and faced uncertainty about mixing and baking parameters at scale.

Business component: Production process

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Scale-up uncertainty resolved through trials
Potential exclusion issues
  • Production after the process was validated (post-commercial production)
Documentation required
  • Scale-up trial records
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Agriculture

Example · Agriculture

Growing-condition experimentation

A grower tested irrigation schedules and substrate mixes to determine whether a crop variety could be grown profitably in a hotter climate zone.

Business component: Growing process for a crop variety

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Controlled plots with recorded variables
  • Reliance on agronomy and plant science
Potential exclusion issues
  • Routine farming practices
  • Weather-driven adjustments without experimental design
Documentation required
  • Plot designs and yield data
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Example · Agriculture

Crop and process optimization

A farm evaluated alternative post-harvest handling methods to reduce spoilage.

Business component: Post-harvest handling process

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Evaluation of alternatives against defined loss targets
Potential exclusion issues
  • Adopting established methods without uncertainty
Documentation required
  • Spoilage measurements by method
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Example · Agriculture

Equipment development

An agricultural business designed a custom harvester attachment for a crop with no commercial equipment available.

Business component: Harvester attachment

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Prototype iterations
  • Field testing
Potential exclusion issues
  • Equipment costs (depreciable, not supplies)
  • Routine repairs
Documentation required
  • Design drawings and revisions
  • Field test notes
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Medical Devices

Example · Medical Devices

Prototype development

A device company developed a new catheter. The overall device used known elements, but the tip geometry needed to navigate tortuous vessels was uncertain.

Business component: Catheter (shrinking back to tip design)

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Shrinking-back to the uncertain subcomponent
  • Bench-top prototypes and simulated-use testing
Potential exclusion issues
  • Regulatory submission preparation
  • Clinical activities after design is final may raise post-production questions
Documentation required
  • Design history file entries
  • Test reports
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Example · Medical Devices

Testing

Engineers ran fatigue and biocompatibility screening on candidate designs to determine which met durability requirements.

Business component: Implantable device component

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Testing of alternatives against uncertain requirements
Potential exclusion issues
  • Routine lot-release testing
Documentation required
  • Verification test protocols
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Example · Medical Devices

Materials

A company evaluated polymer blends for a flexible housing that needed to withstand repeated sterilization cycles.

Business component: Device housing material

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Material trials with sterilization-cycle testing
  • Supplies consumed in trials
Potential exclusion issues
  • Selecting a material with known certified properties
Documentation required
  • Material trial matrices
  • Sterilization test data
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Example · Medical Devices

Mechanical design

Designers iterated a surgical instrument's actuation mechanism to reduce required hand force while maintaining precision.

Business component: Instrument actuation mechanism

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Design iterations with force measurements
Potential exclusion issues
  • Ergonomic styling changes
Documentation required
  • CAD revisions
  • Force test results
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.