Businesses in this industry may conduct activities that potentially meet the qualified-research requirements. Industry alone does not determine eligibility. Explore credits with the R&D Credit Finder.
What R&D can look like
- Developing novel designs beyond code-prescribed solutions.
- Simulation and modeling of alternatives.
- Performance testing of new systems.
Research topics in engineering
Design uncertainty
Engineering work may involve qualified research where the capability, method or appropriate design is uncertain and alternatives are evaluated through analysis, modeling or testing.
Engineering analysis as experimentation
Calculations, modeling and simulation can be a process of experimentation when they evaluate alternatives to resolve uncertainty. Applying a code formula to a known design generally is not.
Client projects and funded research
Much engineering is performed for clients. Whether that research is funded — and therefore excluded — depends on whether payment is contingent on success and whether the firm retains substantial rights in the results.
Potential business components
The four-part test is applied to each business component. Examples in this industry:
- A system or component design for a project
- An analysis method or design tool developed by the firm
- A process design for a client facility
Common technical uncertainties
- Which design satisfies performance requirements under combined loads
- Whether a novel system configuration can meet efficiency targets
- How a system will behave under conditions outside published data
Potential experimentation
- Modeling and simulation of alternatives
- Iterative design and analysis cycles
- Testing of prototypes or scale models
The four-part test in engineering
| Test | Application |
|---|---|
| Permitted purpose | Functional performance of designed systems. |
| Technological in nature | Engineering principles. |
| Uncertainty | Appropriate design unknown at outset. |
| Process of experimentation | Iterative modeling and analysis of alternatives. |
Project examples
Structural analysis
An engineering firm designing an unusual long-span roof could not determine from codes alone whether the proposed system would meet deflection limits. It modeled alternatives and iterated the design.
Business component: Roof structural system design
Potentially qualifying factors
- Uncertainty beyond code-prescribed solutions
- Iterative modeling of alternatives
Potential exclusion issues
- Routine code-compliance calculations
- Funded research if the client pays regardless of outcome and owns the results
Documentation required
- Model iterations
- Design memos
- Contract terms on risk and rights
- Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
- Records of alternatives evaluated and results
- Time allocation for personnel involved
Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.
Design alternatives
A mechanical engineering team evaluated three cooling approaches for an electronics enclosure operating in extreme heat.
Business component: Enclosure thermal design
Potentially qualifying factors
- Evaluation of alternatives with thermal modeling and testing
Potential exclusion issues
- Selecting a standard catalogue solution without uncertainty
Documentation required
- CFD results
- Test data
- Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
- Records of alternatives evaluated and results
- Time allocation for personnel involved
Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.
Simulation
A firm used computational fluid dynamics to evaluate alternative inlet geometries for an industrial fan to reduce noise while maintaining flow.
Business component: Fan inlet design
Potentially qualifying factors
- Simulation as a method of evaluating alternatives
Potential exclusion issues
- Simulations run only to document a known design
Documentation required
- Simulation inputs/outputs
- Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
- Records of alternatives evaluated and results
- Time allocation for personnel involved
Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.
Performance testing
An engineering team tested a new pump control algorithm across operating conditions to determine whether it met efficiency targets.
Business component: Pump control system
Potentially qualifying factors
- Testing designed to resolve performance uncertainty
Potential exclusion issues
- Acceptance testing required after design completion
Documentation required
- Test matrices and results
- Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
- Records of alternatives evaluated and results
- Time allocation for personnel involved
Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.
QRE examples
Wages
- Engineers performing design analysis on uncertain problems
QRE rules: qualified research expenses.
Documentation
- Contract terms (payment contingency, IP rights)
- Design iterations
- Calculations and models
Potential non-qualifying activities
The statutory exclusions in IRC §41(d)(4) — such as research after commercial production, adaptation or duplication of an existing component, routine quality-control testing, foreign research and funded research — apply to engineering projects in the same way as any other industry. The qualified research page lists each exclusion with its source.
Relevant federal rules: four-part test, qualified research, funded research, research location. Build a documentation checklist.
Federal R&D credit considerations
- See funded research and contract research.
- Apply the four-part test to each business component.
- Document the uncertainty at the start of the design, not only the final design.
Industry-specific caveats
- Routine design using established methods is generally not research.
- Contract terms can make otherwise qualifying research funded research.
- Records of alternatives considered are often missing and should be kept during projects.
Start with the federal R&D tax credit and qualified research expenses; estimate with the federal R&D credit calculator.
Common mistakes
- Ignoring fixed-fee vs. time-and-materials payment terms.
- Claiming routine code-compliance design.
State considerations
- Research must be performed in the state; project site location and design office location may differ.
Potentially relevant active state programs: California, Texas, Arizona.
Calculators: California R&D Tax Credit Calculator, Texas R&D Tax Credit Calculator, Arizona R&D Tax Credit Calculator.
Frequently asked questions
Can client-funded engineering qualify?
Only if the firm bears the economic risk of failure and retains substantial rights in the research results. Contract terms must be reviewed.
Official sources
General research and educational information, not legal or tax advice. Rules vary by tax year and taxpayer-specific facts affect results. See the disclaimer.