Transparency & research standards
Research Methodology
How ResearchTaxCredits.org classifies R&D tax credit programs, prioritizes official sources, tracks tax-year changes, and communicates verification status and uncertainty — and where its limits are.
Last updated: October 9, 2026
How information is classified
Program status, research status and calculator status describe different things. A program may be active while its current source verification is pending, and it may have no calculator at all. A verified record says nothing about whether a particular taxpayer qualifies.
| Status | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Active | Current state-level R&D tax credit program identified. |
| Expired | Former state-level R&D credit program; no new credit generation under the expired program.Historical carryforwards and rules for earlier tax years may still be described. |
| No current credit | No current general state-level R&D tax credit identified.Refers to a general R&D tax credit only. Related incentives, where they exist, are listed separately. |
| Under review | Research is not yet complete.No current rules are presented until research is complete. |
| Status | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Verified | Rules reviewed against the official sources identified for the tax years covered. Tax law can change; check the dates shown.Applies only to the program, sources and tax years stated on the page, with a verification date. It is not a blanket statement about every rule on a state page. |
| Researched — current source verification pending | Research compiled from official-source materials; the rules have not yet been verified against the current official documents. |
| Under review | Research is not yet complete. |
| Status | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Calculator verified | The calculation model was checked against the official statute, forms and instructions for the tax years shown with the calculator; any other supported year is labeled not yet verified. Results remain estimates. |
| Calculator implemented — review required | A calculator exists, but its calculation model still requires verification against authoritative sources.No calculator currently carries this status. |
| No calculator | Information only: no reliable estimate can be offered for this program, so none is provided.A reliable estimate cannot be produced from public inputs, the program is expired, or there is no current credit. |
Research verification and calculator verification are separate. A verified state program does not automatically mean its calculator has been verified, and an active program can have no calculator.
Program types
Programs are also typed, so an adjacent incentive is never presented as a general R&D credit simply because it relates to research or innovation. The types used are:
- General R&D credit
- Specialized R&D credit
- R&D employment credit
- R&D property / equipment credit
- Sales tax exemption
- Property tax incentive
- Grant
- Refundable credit feature
- Transferable credit feature
- Historical credit
- Federal-based R&D credit
- Other R&D-related incentive
Current counts for every jurisdiction are on the state research coverage page, the state research table and the state directory.
Source hierarchy
Rules are traced to primary sources, in this order of priority. Priority depends on the issue being researched: an amendment, its effective date or an application process may require reading several primary sources together.
- Statutes and codes (the Internal Revenue Code, including IRC §41, for the federal credit).Primary authority
- The tax authority (the IRS for the federal credit).Primary authority
- Regulations.Primary authority
- Official forms.Forms & instructions
- Official form instructions.Forms & instructions
- Official administrative guidance (notices, bulletins, FAQs, rulings).Administrative guidance
- Official economic-development agencies, for certification- and application-based programs.Administrative guidance
- Enacted legislation.Legislation
Groups match the headings used in source lists across the site: Primary authority, Forms & instructions, Administrative guidance, Legislation. A lower position does not make a source irrelevant.
- Secondary sources may help explain or locate a rule but never replace primary authority. Commercial tax-credit marketing sites and Wikipedia are not used as authorities.
- Each source shows its type, issuing authority, the tax years it covers and the date it was verified.
- Sources are located on the issuing authority’s own website. Where a document could not be opened directly, its cited content was confirmed from text published on that official domain.
- Where a jurisdiction does not publish official online text (for example some state codes), the page says so rather than linking an unofficial copy. If an official URL cannot be confirmed, the page shows a verification warning instead of a guessed link.
- Superseded forms and instructions are kept as historical sources.
Every cited source is listed in the official source library.
When sources conflict
When sources disagree — for example a statute and the current form, or a form and an older FAQ — the page shows both, explains the difference and states which one the explanation and any calculator follow, and why.
- The specific statute or current-year form generally controls over general FAQ language.
- Where a conflict cannot be resolved from the sources, the remaining uncertainty is stated rather than hidden.
Examples: New Hampshire (statute vs. the DP-165 methodology) and Nebraska (LB 901 vs. the current worksheet’s refund language).
From tax authority to calculation model
Each calculator follows the same five steps before it is published.
Identify the formula
From the statute and the official form and instructions for each tax year.
Encode year-specific rules
Rates, thresholds, caps and periods are stored as rule versions, never hard-coded in the interface.
Implement transparently
The engine returns inputs, intermediate values, methodology, warnings, assumptions and sources.
Test
Normal, boundary, zero, invalid-input, missing-data and tax-year transition tests; regression tests for historical years.
Verify or withhold
A calculator is marked verified only after this check. Where an award, certification or allocation decides the amount, the calculator says so instead of estimating it, or no calculator is offered.
Software tests and tax-law correctness are different things. Automated tests confirm that the code implements the modeled rules; a passing test suite does not by itself establish that the interpretation of the law is correct. That is why a calculator is labeled “Calculator verified” only after its model has been checked against the statute, forms and instructions, and “Calculator implemented — review required” until then.
Each calculator page opens with a notice that its results are illustrative estimates, not a tax determination. Browse the calculators; each lists its supported tax years, its official sources and, where recorded, its audit notes.
Tax-year-specific rules
Every rule is stored with the tax years it applies to.
- When a rate, base, cap, refundability rule, carryforward, form or deadline changes, the earlier rule is closed at its last tax year and a new rule is added; nothing is overwritten.
- Calendar effective dates are recorded separately, because a law can take effect on one date and apply to tax years beginning on another.
- A rule verified for one year is never applied to the next year by assumption.
- Calculators list the tax years they support and produce no estimate for any other year. Selecting another year shows “This calculator has not yet been verified for tax year [year]”.
Significant changes are listed in the state R&D tax credit changes directory and the change log.
Keeping historical rules distinct
Expired and repealed programs remain documented with their effective periods and carryforward notes, and are labeled historical.
- A historical program is not available for new claims. Its rules can still matter for earlier tax years and carryforwards.
- Superseded forms and instructions are kept as historical sources.
- Research updates keep their original wording and dates; current status always comes from the jurisdiction’s current record.
Historical programs appear on each state page, and historical forms stay listed in the forms library.
Making uncertainty visible
The site does not publish subjective confidence scores. Uncertainty is shown through the three separate status fields above, through source URL status, through calculator warnings when a parameter’s application to a year was not confirmed, and through labels that separate what an authority states from what the site calculates or interprets.
| Information type | How it is represented |
|---|---|
| Statutory rule | A labeled callout stating what the statute provides; the statute is listed in the page's sources. |
| Official guidance | A labeled callout for what forms, instructions or agency guidance state; the source is listed in the page's sources. |
| ResearchTaxCredits calculation | Labeled as the site's own calculation from stated inputs and rules, not an official figure. |
| ResearchTaxCredits interpretation | Labeled as the site's reading of the sources. It does not carry the authority of a statute or regulation. |
| Estimated result | Calculator output for the inputs and tax year shown; never a determination of eligibility or allowable credit. |
| Source conflict | Both sources are shown, with the difference explained and which one the page and any calculator follow. |
| Tax-year specific — verify applicable law | Marks rules that apply only to stated tax years. |
| Historical rule | Marks rules for expired programs or earlier tax years. |
| Important limitation | Marks a limit on what the research or a calculator covers. |
| Professional review recommended | Marks questions that depend on case-specific facts and need qualified advice. |
What ‘Rules last verified’ means
“Rules last verified” is the date a record’s rules were reviewed against the official sources identified on that page, for the scope and tax years stated there.
- Pages show when content was last reviewed, when the rules were last verified and which tax years they cover — separately. Research dates and verification dates are distinct.
- A verification date is not a promise that the law has not changed since. Statutes, forms, instructions and guidance can change afterward.
- Records are flagged for re-review when they are about 12 months old or when a change is reported. The flag prompts a review; it is not an expiry date and does not mean every record is refreshed automatically.
- Records with open questions keep the research status that reflects them, such as “Researched — current source verification pending” or “Under review”.
Official source records and URL status
Each source record shows its title, issuing authority, citation where available, and when it was verified or reviewed. Its URL has one of two statuses:
- Located on official domain
- The address was found on the issuing authority's own site. On its own this does not establish that the document's content was verified; the verification date and basis are shown separately.
- Requires verification
- A specific official URL has not been confirmed. The page shows “Official source URL requires verification” instead of a guessed link.
Source cited on this page
All sources are in the official source library.
Corrections, independence and limitations
Reported errors are checked against the official source for the affected tax year and corrected in the underlying record. See the corrections policy.
ResearchTaxCredits.org is independent of the IRS, the U.S. Treasury and every state government. No research conclusion is influenced by advertisers, referral partners or any party that benefits from a particular reading of the law. See the editorial policy.
- Research describes the law and official guidance; it is not tax advice.
- Eligibility and credit amounts depend on taxpayer-specific facts, documentation and filings.
- Calculator results are estimates for the tax years and inputs shown.
- Official sources change; check the current-year forms and instructions before filing.