The four tests

TestQuestionCommon pitfall
Permitted purposeDoes the research relate to a new or improved function, performance, reliability or quality?Claiming aesthetic, cosmetic or style changes
Technological in natureDoes the process of experimentation rely on hard sciences, engineering or computer science?Relying on market research or business judgment
Elimination of uncertaintyWas there uncertainty about capability, method or appropriate design at the outset?Describing business risk rather than technical uncertainty
Process of experimentationDid substantially all activities evaluate alternatives through modeling, simulation or trial and error?Routine implementation of a known solution

Applied per business component

The tests are applied to each business component separately. A company-wide conclusion ("we are an innovative company") does not establish qualification. If a whole product fails, the shrinking-back rule looks at subcomponents.

Worked illustrations

Example · Software

Database optimization

Queries on a multi-tenant database degraded as data grew. The team did not know whether partitioning, alternative indexing or a columnar store would restore performance without breaking consistency guarantees.

Business component: Data layer of a commercial SaaS product

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Uncertainty about method and design
  • Benchmarking of alternative schemas and indexes
  • Iterative refinement based on measured results
Potential exclusion issues
  • Applying a vendor's documented tuning guide without uncertainty
  • Routine maintenance and monitoring
  • Data migration after the design was settled
Documentation required
  • Benchmark scripts and results
  • Tickets linking experiments to findings
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Example · Food & Beverage

Shelf-life experimentation

A producer wanted to extend refrigerated shelf life from 21 to 45 days. It tested preservation methods and packaging atmospheres with microbial challenge studies.

Business component: Product formulation and packaging process

Potentially qualifying factors
  • Measurable reliability/quality objective
  • Challenge studies evaluating alternatives
Potential exclusion issues
  • Routine shelf-life verification of an established product
  • Regulatory labeling work
Documentation required
  • Challenge-study protocols and results
  • Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
  • Records of alternatives evaluated and results
  • Time allocation for personnel involved

Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.

Not the same as the Section G 80%/Top 50 rule

See Form 6765 Section G and the 2026 Form 6765 guide.

Frequently asked questions

What does 'substantially all' mean?

The regulations treat the process-of-experimentation test as met if 80% or more of the research activities for the business component (measured on a cost or other consistently applied reasonable basis) constitute elements of a process of experimentation. This is a qualification test and is unrelated to the Form 6765 Section G requirement that required filers report business components covering at least 80% of QREs.

Is the four-part test the same for state credits?

Most state credits incorporate the federal §41 definition of qualified research, but states can modify it — for example by limiting research to activity conducted in the state. Check each state page.

Official sources

Explore State R&D Tax Credits

A neutral selection of state research, listed alphabetically. A federal credit does not determine a state credit: some state programs incorporate federal concepts, while others use state-specific definitions and calculations.

All state R&D tax credits · Compare state rules · State changes by year

General research and educational information, not legal or tax advice. Rules may vary by tax year and taxpayer-specific facts may affect results. See the disclaimer.