Businesses in this industry may conduct activities that potentially meet the qualified-research requirements. Industry alone does not determine eligibility. Explore credits with the R&D Credit Finder.
What R&D can look like
- Designing new or improved products to meet performance specifications.
- Developing new manufacturing processes or tooling.
- Material and process trials to improve yield or reliability.
- Prototyping and destructive testing.
Research topics in manufacturing
Product development
Designing new or improved products where performance, durability or manufacturability is uncertain may involve qualified research, evaluated through modeling, prototypes and testing.
Materials
Selecting or formulating materials whose behavior under the product's conditions is unknown — strength, fatigue, corrosion, thermal properties — may involve experimentation with alternatives.
Process development and improvements
A manufacturing process is itself a business component. Developing a new process or improving yield, cycle time or quality where the method is uncertain may qualify, even if the product is unchanged.
Tooling and automation
Designing tooling, fixtures or automated cells where the design that will achieve tolerances or throughput is uncertain may involve qualified research. Purchasing standard equipment does not.
CAD, simulation and testing
Computer-aided design, finite element analysis and simulation are methods of experimentation when used to evaluate alternatives. Routine drafting of a settled design is not.
Prototypes
Prototype materials may be supply QREs. A pilot model or prototype that is depreciable property is not a supply, and its cost is not a QRE.
Potential business components
The four-part test is applied to each business component. Examples in this industry:
- A new or improved product line
- A production process or process step
- Tooling, dies or fixtures developed in-house
- An automated assembly or inspection cell
Common technical uncertainties
- Whether a design meets load, heat or fatigue requirements
- Which process parameters achieve a target yield
- Whether tooling can hold required tolerances at production speed
Potential experimentation
- Design of experiments on process parameters
- Prototype builds with destructive and life testing
- Simulation (FEA, CFD) of alternatives
- Plant trials with measured outcomes
The four-part test in manufacturing
| Test | Application |
|---|---|
| Permitted purpose | Function, performance, reliability or quality of products or processes. |
| Technological in nature | Engineering and materials science. |
| Uncertainty | Whether a design or process can achieve requirements. |
| Process of experimentation | Designed experiments, FEA, trials and prototypes. |
Project examples
Material testing
A manufacturer needed a lighter bracket that would survive cyclic loading. It tested three alloys and two heat treatments to failure.
Business component: Lightweight bracket (product)
Potentially qualifying factors
- Uncertainty about capability and design
- Destructive testing of alternatives
- Engineering analysis of failure modes
Potential exclusion issues
- Routine incoming material inspection
- Testing to confirm specification compliance for production lots
Documentation required
- Test protocols and results
- Material consumption records
- Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
- Records of alternatives evaluated and results
- Time allocation for personnel involved
Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.
Process optimization
A plant sought to raise yield on a stamping line. Engineers evaluated die designs and press parameters in controlled trials.
Business component: Stamping process (plant process)
Potentially qualifying factors
- Process treated as separate business component
- Designed experiments with recorded parameters
Potential exclusion issues
- Routine adjustments by operators
- Efficiency studies without technical uncertainty
Documentation required
- Design-of-experiments plans
- Yield data
- Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
- Records of alternatives evaluated and results
- Time allocation for personnel involved
Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.
Tolerance refinement
A precision component required tolerances tighter than the shop had achieved. Machinists and engineers trialed tooling paths, fixtures and thermal controls.
Business component: Precision shaft (product) and machining method (process)
Potentially qualifying factors
- Uncertainty about method to achieve tolerance
- Iterative trials with measurement data
Potential exclusion issues
- Routine first-article inspection
- Production runs after the method was established
Documentation required
- CMM measurement data by trial
- Fixture design iterations
- Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
- Records of alternatives evaluated and results
- Time allocation for personnel involved
Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.
Tooling development
A manufacturer designed new injection-mold tooling for a part with complex geometry. The overall product was a known design, but the tooling's cooling layout was uncertain.
Business component: Mold tooling (shrinking back from the finished product)
Potentially qualifying factors
- Shrinking-back to the tooling subcomponent where uncertainty existed
- Mold-flow simulation of cooling alternatives
Potential exclusion issues
- Duplicating existing tooling
- Tooling that is depreciable property (not a supply QRE)
Documentation required
- Simulation files
- Tooling design revisions
- Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
- Records of alternatives evaluated and results
- Time allocation for personnel involved
Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.
Load testing
An equipment maker redesigned a frame to carry higher loads and was uncertain which cross-section would meet fatigue targets. It combined FEA with physical load tests.
Business component: Equipment frame
Potentially qualifying factors
- Modeling plus physical testing
- Design changes driven by results
Potential exclusion issues
- Certification testing of a finished design
- Tests required by a customer contract that funds the work
Documentation required
- FEA models
- Load-test reports
- Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
- Records of alternatives evaluated and results
- Time allocation for personnel involved
Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.
Prototype development
A company built functional prototypes of a new valve to determine whether a novel seal geometry would prevent leakage at high pressure.
Business component: High-pressure valve
Potentially qualifying factors
- Prototypes built to test uncertain designs
- Supplies consumed in prototypes
Potential exclusion issues
- Prototypes later sold to customers
- Pre-production pilot runs after design freeze
Documentation required
- Prototype build records
- Leak-test results
- Contemporaneous records of the uncertainty at the outset
- Records of alternatives evaluated and results
- Time allocation for personnel involved
Illustrative example. Qualification depends on the specific facts of each business component and is not automatic.
QRE examples
Wages
- Design engineers
- Machinists building test fixtures (direct support)
Supplies
- Materials consumed in trials and prototypes
Contract research
- Outside testing labs under qualifying agreements
QRE rules: qualified research expenses.
Documentation
- Engineering change records
- Test data
- Bills of material for prototypes
- Trial logs
Potential non-qualifying activities
The statutory exclusions in IRC §41(d)(4) — such as research after commercial production, adaptation or duplication of an existing component, routine quality-control testing, foreign research and funded research — apply to manufacturing projects in the same way as any other industry. The qualified research page lists each exclusion with its source.
Relevant federal rules: four-part test, qualified research, funded research, research location. Build a documentation checklist.
Federal R&D credit considerations
- Qualified supplies exclude depreciable property and general supplies.
- Production-floor employees' wages may be QREs only for time spent performing, supervising or directly supporting qualified research — see qualified wages.
- Research ends when the component is ready for commercial production — see process of experimentation.
Industry-specific caveats
- Routine quality-control testing and inspection are excluded.
- Scrap from normal production is not a research supply.
- Costs of trial runs need to be separated from saleable production.
Start with the federal R&D tax credit and qualified research expenses; estimate with the federal R&D credit calculator.
Common mistakes
- Including routine quality control.
- Claiming depreciable equipment as supplies.
- Claiming prototypes sold to customers.
State considerations
- Many state programs target manufacturing; Florida limits its credit to qualified target industries including manufacturing.
- Sales-tax exemptions for R&D equipment are separate incentives.
Potentially relevant active state programs: Ohio, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Georgia, Wisconsin.
Calculators: Ohio R&D Tax Credit Calculator, Michigan R&D Tax Credit Calculator, Pennsylvania R&D Tax Credit Calculator, Georgia R&D Tax Credit Calculator, Wisconsin R&D Tax Credit Calculator.
Frequently asked questions
Can process improvements qualify?
Yes, if they meet the four-part test. The process is evaluated as its own business component.
Official sources
General research and educational information, not legal or tax advice. Rules vary by tax year and taxpayer-specific facts affect results. See the disclaimer.