1. Define the business component
The test is applied to each business component — a product, process, computer software, technique, formula or invention held for sale, lease or license, or used in the taxpayer's trade or business. Name the component precisely (for example, "second-generation pump impeller" rather than "engineering"). If the whole component does not qualify, the shrinking-back rule applies the test to the next most significant subset of elements.
2. Work through the four tests
| Test | Questions to answer | Rule page |
|---|---|---|
| Permitted purpose | What new or improved function, performance, reliability or quality was sought? Is the purpose functional rather than aesthetic or cosmetic? | Permitted purpose |
| Technological in nature | Which principles of the physical or biological sciences, engineering or computer science did the work rely on? | Technological in nature |
| Elimination of uncertainty | At the outset, what was uncertain about the capability, the method or the appropriate design? | Technical uncertainty |
| Process of experimentation | What alternatives were identified, and how were they evaluated (modeling, simulation, testing, trial and error)? Did substantially all (80% or more) of the activities constitute experimentation? | Process of experimentation |
3. Compare with paired examples
| Test | May meet the test | Likely does not meet the test |
|---|---|---|
| Permitted purpose | Improving pump efficiency | Changing the pump housing color |
| Technological in nature | Thermal modeling of an enclosure | A customer preference survey |
| Uncertainty | Unknown whether an alloy survives cyclic loading | Selecting a bolt from a standard load table |
| Process of experimentation | Testing three alloy candidates to failure | Building to a finished drawing |
4. Check the exclusions
Even research that meets all four tests is excluded if it is research after commercial production, adaptation or duplication of an existing business component, surveys and routine data collection, research conducted outside the United States, research in the social sciences or humanities, or research funded by another person. Internal-use software must also meet the high threshold of innovation test.
5. Record the analysis
- Write down the answers to each question with references to contemporaneous records (designs, test results, code history).
- Identify the people who performed, supervised or supported the qualified activities — this feeds the wage allocation.
- Keep the analysis per business component; it also supports Form 6765 Section G reporting where required.
The R&D project assessment tool organizes these questions and produces preliminary research considerations, not a qualification determination.
Frequently asked questions
Does failure mean the research did not qualify?
No. Success is not required. What matters is whether the activities were undertaken to eliminate technical uncertainty through a process of experimentation.
Is the Section G 80% rule part of the four-part test?
No. The Section G 80% / Top 50 framework is a reporting rule measured in QRE dollars. The 80% substantially-all requirement is part of the process of experimentation test.
Official sources
General research and educational information, not legal or tax advice. Rules may vary by tax year and taxpayer-specific facts may affect results. See the disclaimer.